--- title: Mobile Payment Compatibility at Festivals - Round 1 description: Part One of two-part series, Key Limers field test PayPal and Google Wallet apps on both iPhone and Android smartphones. Check out their findings. image: https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/hs-fs/file-3421841125-png/blog-files/photo-1-169x300.png --- [![Key Lime Logo](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Key%20Lime%20Logo.png?width=200&height=39&name=Key%20Lime%20Logo.png "Key Lime Logo")](https://keylimeinteractive.com/) - SERVICES - [All Services](https://keylimeinteractive.com/services) - [UX Strategy](https://keylimeinteractive.com/ux-strategy-design/) - [User Research](https://keylimeinteractive.com/user-research/) - [UX/UI Design](https://keylimeinteractive.com/ux-design-strategy/) - [EmTech Strategy](https://keylimeinteractive.com/emerging-technology/) - OUR WORK - [Our Approach](https://dev.keylimeinteractive.com/our-approach/) - [Enterprise Clients](https://keylimeinteractive.com/work/) - [Public Sector](https://keylimeinteractive.com/public-sector-gsa-schedule/) - [ABOUT US](https://keylimeinteractive.com/about-us/) - [Who We Are](https://keylimeinteractive.com/about-us/) - [People](https://keylimeinteractive.com/our-team/) - [Careers](https://workforcenow.adp.com/mascsr/default/mdf/recruitment/recruitment.html?cid=1eb079d3-bb50-438a-a731-eaa18a982193&ccId=19000101_000001&lang=en_US) - INSIGHTS - [CX Blog](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com) - [Events](https://keylimeinteractive.com/upcoming-events/) - [Competitive Indexes](https://keylimeinteractive.com/reports/#rankings) - [White Papers](https://keylimeinteractive.com/reports/) - [CONTACT US](https://keylimeinteractive.com/contact/) [![](https://keylimeinteractive.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/key-lime-interactive.svg)](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/) - [What We Do](https://keylimeinteractive.com/ux-research-services/) - [Proven Process](https://keylimeinteractive.com/proven-process/) - [About Us](https://keylimeinteractive.com/about-us/) - [Meet Our Team](https://keylimeinteractive.com/our-team/) - [Careers](https://keylimeinteractive.com/careers/) - [News](https://keylimeinteractive.com/news/) - [Blog](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/) - Resources - [Case Studies](https://keylimeinteractive.com/case-studies/) - [Events](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/events) - [What We Do](https://keylimeinteractive.com/ux-research-services/) - [Proven Process](https://keylimeinteractive.com/proven-process/) - [About Us](https://keylimeinteractive.com/about-us/) - [Meet Our Team](https://keylimeinteractive.com/our-team/) - [Careers](https://keylimeinteractive.com/careers/) - [News](https://keylimeinteractive.com/news/) - [Blog](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/) - Resources - [Case Studies](https://keylimeinteractive.com/case-studies/) - [Events](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/events) [Contact us](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/contact) [![](https://keylimeinteractive.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/key-lime-interactive.svg)](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/) - [What We Do](https://keylimeinteractive.com/ux-research-services/) - [Proven Process](https://keylimeinteractive.com/proven-process/) - [About Us](https://keylimeinteractive.com/about-us/) - [Meet Our Team](https://keylimeinteractive.com/our-team/) - [Careers](https://keylimeinteractive.com/careers/) - [News](https://keylimeinteractive.com/news/) - [Blog](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/) - Resources - [Case Studies](https://keylimeinteractive.com/case-studies/) - [Events](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/events) - [What We Do](https://keylimeinteractive.com/ux-research-services/) - [Proven Process](https://keylimeinteractive.com/proven-process/) - [About Us](https://keylimeinteractive.com/about-us/) - [Meet Our Team](https://keylimeinteractive.com/our-team/) - [Careers](https://keylimeinteractive.com/careers/) - [News](https://keylimeinteractive.com/news/) - [Blog](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/) - Resources - [Case Studies](https://keylimeinteractive.com/case-studies/) - [Events](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/events) [Contact us](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/contact) - - - # Mobile Payment Compatibility at Festivals - Round 1 [By Key Lime Interactive](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/author/key-lime-interactive) August 07, 2014 [App Development](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/app-development) - [Tweet](https://twitter.com/share) ![](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/hs-fs/file-3421841125-png/blog-files/photo-1-169x300.png) *After a challenging experience with mobile payments at a New York music festival, our researchers decided to get together and assess two of the leading mobile payment options currently on the market. In Part One of this two-part series, we field test PayPal and Google Wallet apps on both iPhone and Android smartphones. Next month, we’ll review the mobile payment landscape and share some interesting new developments.* Let's see where Kathleen Henning and Phil McGuinness stand on these mobile giants. **Kathleen:** As I was preparing to attend the Governor’s Ball festival this summer, I was super psyched. Not only did they have an amazing lineup, but the food & drink section asked for my credit card information so I could make mobile payments. Since I hate carrying cash (and really anything), this was a dream come true for me. Unfortunately, it was a little too good to be true. I entered all of my information only to find that no one was accepting the GovBall app as payment. Instead, there was the PayPal app… Most festivals, for better or worse, are known for having notoriously awful cell service. GovBall was no exception. Using the PayPal app required downloading it, logging in, taking a picture of yourself, and saving your account information. All of those steps required far more Internet speed than was available. Day 1 I had no luck. Day 2 I was able to purchase free Brooklyn Soda Works. Day 3 the vendors I tried weren’t accepting it anymore because of technical failure.  [![Some stores offered coupons to use when checking in with PayPal](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/hs-fs/file-3421841125-png/blog-files/photo-1-169x300.png?width=122&height=216&name=photo-1-169x300.png)](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/hs-fs/file-3421841125-png/blog-files/photo-1-169x300.png) *Some stores offered coupons to use when checking in with PayPal.* This experience got me thinking, does this app work any better with a stronger signal? Was my experience simply based on the context of the festival? I opened up the PayPal app, looked through the local businesses available, and took a trip to Van Leeuwen’s for a (mostly free) scoop of ice cream with ridiculously delicious fudge. The app worked! And then it crashed my iPhone. However I was able to pay and get the $5 coupon discount and, more importantly, enjoy a little piece of ice cream heaven. **Phil:** After Kathleen and I discussed her experience, I went ahead and tested the take out ordering for the PayPal app on Android. I found that it works like any food ordering app. All mobile ordering relies squarely on the structure and capabilities of the Eat24Hours service. My experience with setup was fairly easy, although you have to enter a lot of basic information, including a picture, which might deter some people. *Would you want to include a selfie?* [![Would you want to include a selfie?](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/hs-fs/file-3421841135-jpg/blog-files/photo-1-169x300.jpg?width=102&height=182&name=photo-1-169x300.jpg)](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/hs-fs/file-3421841135-jpg/blog-files/photo-1-169x300.jpg)After set up, I found that the app was slowing down the ordering process with numerous errors. At first the PayPal app was stuck on the “delivery” setting for food, and even when I toggled the setting to “takeout” the delivery fee and minimum order remained on screen. The app’s ordering function also repeatedly timed out with a plain text screen reporting an unspecified error. On top of all this, the ordering process was generally very slow to load. Feeling discouraged, I shut down the app for the day and ordered through other means. [![One error encountered with PayPal: Despite selecting "Pickup" the app still thought I was ordering "Delivery".](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/hs-fs/file-3421841145-jpg/blog-files/pickup-delivery-issue-e1407402418327-197x300.jpg "One error encountered with PayPal: Despite selecting \"Pickup\" the app still thought I was ordering \"Delivery\".")](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/hs-fs/file-3421841145-jpg/blog-files/pickup-delivery-issue-e1407402418327-197x300.jpg) *One error encountered with PayPal: Despite selecting "Pickup" the app still thought I was ordering "Delivery"*. The next day I opened the app again to order some lunch, and thankfully the process went smoothly. I was able to pick up my food without any hiccups. I hope that the errors Kathleen and I experienced will be worked out over time, so the app can become a more reliable source of ordering. *Google Wallet doesn’t provide a method to find local stores where payment is accepted, limiting its effectiveness as a wallet or credit card replacement.* ![](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/hs-fs/file-3421841155-jpg/blog-files/google-wallet-home-e1407402799715-183x300.jpg?width=183&height=300&name=google-wallet-home-e1407402799715-183x300.jpg)I also reviewed Google Wallet on Android, a mobile payment app whose main point of differentiation is the use of Near Field Communication (NFC) for point-of-sale payments. Since I had already used Google Payments in the past, the setup was quick and easy. The trouble started when I tried to find a location to use the payment method. Google’s site doesn’t provide any list of merchants where Google Wallet payments are accepted. This may be due to vendors being slow to adopt NFC, which is necessary for this type of payment to spread. Unfortunately this leaves the user to find locations themselves, making this convenient method of payment not so convenient. I spent a week in Silicon Valley and a week traveling and I didn't find a single location to make a payment with Google Wallet. With limited adoption and no means for finding out where this type of mobile payment is accepted, Google Wallet is far from replacing my trusted standard leather wallet. **Kathleen:** In this day and age, there’s a lot of potential for mobile payment systems to streamline a manual process. I was at a concert recently where the luxury box seats were offered a paper menu to select menu items and have them brought to your seat. This section was organized by Live Nation, the international promoter. A setting like this one would be perfect for mobile payments. If I could log into my Live Nation app, select what I want from the menu, hit submit, and have it delivered to my seat, I would be so happy! **In conclusion:** There are definitely still some usability issues in this area, but we here at Key Lime Interactive are super excited about the future of mobile payments, especially at concerts and music festivals! Next month, we’ll review the current mobile payment landscape, including some novel new approaches to address problems like those Kathleen and Phil encountered above. Until next month... ###### More by this Author [Key Lime Interactive](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/author/key-lime-interactive) ##### You might also like ![UX Research in a Fast-Paced Development Cycle](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/hubfs/user-interface-1655006__480.png) [UX Research in a Fast-Paced Development Cycle](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/ux-research-in-a-fast-paced-development-cycle) August 07, 2014 ![The UX of Running Apps](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/hubfs/runner.jpg) [The UX of Running Apps](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/the-ux-of-running-apps) August 07, 2014 ![Is Panera Leading the Way for Restaurants With Their In-Store Experience?](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/hubfs/Picture2-3.png) [Is Panera Leading the Way for Restaurants With Their In-Store Experience?](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/is-panera-leading-the-way-for-restaurants-with-their-in-store-experience) August 07, 2014 #### Comments [Add Comment](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/mobile-payment-compatibility-at-festivals-round-1#comment-form) ABOUT KLI [Key Lime Interactive](https://keylimeinteractive.com/about-us)is a user experience research and service design agency, with a sweet spot for emerging technology. As UX experts, our goal is to make your life easier, optimize user experiences, and make the world a better place. - [Recent](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/mobile-payment-compatibility-at-festivals-round-1#tabs-0) - [Popular](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/mobile-payment-compatibility-at-festivals-round-1#tabs-1) ![Upsell with Purpose: Fueling SaaS Growth Through User Insight](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/hubfs/Multiethnic%20group%20of%20young%20people%20sitting%20in%20conference%20room%20and%20brainstorming%20on%20business%20meeting.jpeg) [Upsell with Purpose: Fueling SaaS Growth Through User Insight](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/upselling-in-a-saas-environment-with-a-user-centric-approach) Aug 21, 2024 ![5 Ways to Get the Most Out of Working with a UX Research Consultant](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/hubfs/Attractive%20businessman%20speaking%20with%20fellow%20coworkers.jpeg) [5 Ways to Get the Most Out of Working with a UX Research Consultant](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/5-ways-to-get-the-most-out-of-working-with-a-ux-research-consultant) Aug 21, 2024 ![Designing Engagement Through Micro-Interactions](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/hubfs/AI-Generated%20Media/Images/A%20closeup%20shot%20of%20a%20finger%20gently%20tapping%20a%20digital%20button%20on%20a%20sleek%2c%20modern%20interface.jpeg) [Designing Engagement Through Micro-Interactions](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/the-significance-of-micro-interactions-in-shaping-user-engagement-and-experience) Aug 21, 2024 ![What is the Keystroke-Level Model?](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/hubfs/Keystroke.jpg) [What is the Keystroke-Level Model?](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/what-is-the-keystroke-level-model) Aug 21, 2024 ![Current-State vs. Future-State Journey Mapping](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/hubfs/destination-2386255_1280.jpg) [Current-State vs. Future-State Journey Mapping](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/current-state-vs.-future-state-journey-mapping) Aug 21, 2024 ![A History of Voice Technology](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/hubfs/Screen%20Shot%202020-08-11%20at%2012.18.34%20PM.png) [A History of Voice Technology](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/history-of-voice-technology) Aug 21, 2024 Create a UX Strategy [![key-lime-interactive-ux](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/hs-fs/hubfs/key-lime-interactive-ux.png?width=635&height=634&name=key-lime-interactive-ux.png)](https://keylimeinteractive.com/ux-strategy-design) ### Post By Topics - [Research Methods](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/research-methods) - [UX Strategy](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/ux-strategy) - [Events & News](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/events-news) - [UX Research](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/ux-research) - [User Experience](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/user-experience) - [User Interface](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/user-interface) - [UX](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/ux) - [News](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/news) - [Mobile UX](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/mobile-ux) - [Usability Testing](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/usability-testing) - [Competitive Research](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/competitive-research) - [UX Design](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/ux-design) - [Eye tracking & Biometrics](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/eye-tracking-biometrics) - [Qualitative Research](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/qualitative-research) - [Customer Experience](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/customer-experience) - [Journey Mapping](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/journey-mapping) - [DEI](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/dei) - [Remote Testing](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/remote-testing) - [User Experience Consultant](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/user-experience-consultant) - [VR](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/vr) - [XR](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/xr) - [Multicultural UX](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/multicultural-ux) - [Mobile Banking](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/mobile-banking) - [Quantitative Research](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/quantitative-research) - [App Development](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/app-development) - [User Experience Research Studies](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/user-experience-research-studies) - [Diversity Equity Inclusion](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/diversity-equity-inclusion) - [UI](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/ui) - [Voice Technology](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/voice-technology) - [Accessibility](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/accessibility) - [Behavioral Personas](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/behavioral-personas) - [Diary Study & Ethnography](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/diary-study-ethnography) - [Global Research](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/global-research) - [Inclusivity Index](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/inclusivity-index) - [User Testing](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/user-testing) - [Card Sort & Tree Test](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/card-sort-tree-test) - [Human-first Approach](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/human-first-approach) - [Personalization](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/personalization) - [CX](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/cx) - [Diary Study](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/diary-study) - [In-Depth Interviews](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/in-depth-interviews) - [Inclusivity](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/inclusivity) - [A/B Testing](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/a-b-testing) - [CX Research](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/cx-research) - [IDIs](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/idis) - [Bias](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/bias) - [Personas](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/personas) - [Research Participant Recruitment](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/research-participant-recruitment) - [Usability](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/usability) - [Women in UX](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/women-in-ux) - [Workshops](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/workshops) - [Customer Journey Mapping](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/customer-journey-mapping) - [Remote Research](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/remote-research) - [Research Analysis](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/research-analysis) - [UX Methods](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/ux-methods) - [Webinars](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/webinars) - [Anthropology](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/anthropology) - [Competitive Benchmarking](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/competitive-benchmarking) - [Competitive Insights](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/competitive-insights) - [Competitive Intelligence](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/competitive-intelligence) - [Confirmation Bias](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/confirmation-bias) - [Ethnography](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/ethnography) - [Gaming](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/gaming) - [Healthcare CX Design](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/healthcare-cx-design) - [Healthcare Customer Experience Design](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/healthcare-customer-experience-design) - [Heuristics](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/heuristics) - [Unmoderated](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/unmoderated) - [sample size calculation](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/sample-size-calculation) - [AI development](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/ai-development) - [Biometrics](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/biometrics) - [Communication](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/communication) - [Competitive Intelligence Analysis](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/competitive-intelligence-analysis) - [Concept Testing](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/concept-testing) - [Consultant](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/consultant) - [Custom Projects](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/custom-projects) - [Dedicated Services](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/dedicated-services) - [Digital Divide](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/digital-divide) - [Impact](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/impact) - [Keystroke Level Model](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/keystroke-level-model) - [Literature Review](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/literature-review) - [Negotiation in UX](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/negotiation-in-ux) - [Nonprofit UX](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/nonprofit-ux) - [Presentation](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/presentation) - [Rapid Research](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/rapid-research) - [Report](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/report) - [SaaS](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/saas) - [UX Templates](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/ux-templates) - [World Usability Day](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/world-usability-day) - [digital design](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/digital-design) - [persona](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/persona) - [user engagement](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/topic/user-engagement) ![ ](https://keylimeinteractive.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/05/aicpa-soc-certified.png) ![Logo of the National Minority Supplier Development Council with colorful abstract shapes and text.](https://keylimeinteractive.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/05/NMSDC-Logo-NATIONAL-1024x716.jpg) ![Logo with the text "Insights Association" and colorful squares forming a pattern above the text.](https://keylimeinteractive.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/insights-association-logo-v2.png) ![](https://keylimeinteractive.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/key-lime-interactive.svg) Your Trusted Partner for UX Research Key Lime Interactive - [What We Do](https://keylimeinteractive.com/ux-research-services/) - [Proven Process](https://keylimeinteractive.com/proven-process/) Resources - [Case Studies](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/case-studies) - [Events + Workshops](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/events) - [Blog](https://info.keylimeinteractive.com/) Company - [About Us](https://keylimeinteractive.com/about-us/) - [Meet Our Team](https://keylimeinteractive.com/our-team/) - [Careers](https://keylimeinteractive.com/careers/) - [News](https://keylimeinteractive.com/news/) - [Security & Compliance](https://app.vanta.com/keylimeinteractive.com/trust/cylnxu23wx6pzvej7bloh9) - [Public Sector GSA](https://keylimeinteractive.com/public-sector-gsa-schedule/) Get in touch - [Contact Us](https://keylimeinteractive.com/contact) © 2025 All Rights Reserved. - [Privacy Policy](https://keylimeinteractive.com/privacy-policy/) - [Terms of Use](https://keylimeinteractive.com/terms/)